Gay Christians and the Robertson Controversy

I ended yesterday with yet another viewing of Love Actually. After a day bustling with tweets, posts, and articles stating concerns from both sides of the culture war regarding the Phil Robertson controversy (with both sides making legitimate points), it was good to get in touch with some of the fundamental human questions most gay Christians are concerned about: questions of faithfulness, friendship, love, longing, and belonging.

Whenever there’s an explosion in the culture war, it seems like the real people with genuine human struggles are shelved while we argue about rights and agendas. There are legitimate concerns that need to be addressed: How do we share our views in ways that highlight the value and dignity of people made in the image of God? Is there room for Christians to share their unpopular views freely, as there seems to be for folks who hold different values? When someone is directly asked for their opinions, are we ready to actually hear them? And in hearing them, can we respectfully agree or disagree instead of waging war? Can we consider fighting for the marginalized as passionately as we fight other sides in the debate?

There are serious questions that need to be addressed, and I’m grateful for thoughtful people who contribute in a kind manner. But in the midst of the volatile debates, I hope you’ll consider the emotionally complex human experience of the people you’re talking about. When you get riled up about the Gay Agenda and stand strong with someone like Phil when he shares his views in (what seems to us) a derogatory manner, it’s difficult for us to know whether you agree with Phil’s conservative Christian values, or if you agree with his inconsiderate statements that imply we’d be straight if we woke up to the glory of the opposite sex’s genitals.

It’s hard to figure out if we’re an “us” or a “them” when we’re both gay and Christian. I know you might feel like you’re talking about a liberal agenda that’s seeking to infringe on religious freedom, but that’s not the case with most gay people. Many of us share your values and seek daily to say “no” to our longings in order to say “yes” to the God we love with all our hearts. We do it in a culture that often tells us we’re crazy; we do it among Christians who often act like we don’t exist.

But we do exist. We’re sitting in small groups with you. We’re reading your facebook feeds, listening to your rants, resonating with your concerns yet feeling a strange sense of un-belonging at the same time. If I feel that—someone who’s open and accepted as a celibate gay Christian—I can’t imagine how those struggling in silence experience all of this. I can’t imagine how the 16 year old sitting in the family room feels.

I don’t want to minimize the concerns I hear Christians voicing—I share many of your concerns regarding Phil’s suspension for expressing his views. But I hope you’ll consider those among you who perceive you’re fighting against them when you rally around petitions about standing for truth, like Preston Sprinkle does in this excellent post. I hope you’ll consider standing for truth in ways that express solidarity with gay people. I hope you’ll seek ways to be a nourishing voice in the midst of culture war explosions that often demean the people argued about. I hope you’ll remember that many gay Christians are seeking to honor the Lord, to love others well, and to thrive in the midst of a church culture that can make it difficult to flourish.

When I read all of Phil’s statements, I found myself appreciating the fact that he emphasized loving others and leaving God to judge. I felt like Phil and I would get on alright if we launched into an off-road excursion together. I believe the best about Phil because I’ve gotten to know others like him, and I know their hearts are much softer than their words can sound. In the same way, I hope you’ll get to know more gay people and realize we’re not the enemy and we don’t have an agenda—we’re a group of people grappling with what it means to love, remain faithful, and flourish in your churches.

Julie Rodgers

Julie Rodgers shares life with inner city youth in West Dallas. She also writes and speaks about faith and sexuality, so check out her blog or find her on Twitter:@Julie_rodgers.

10 thoughts on “Gay Christians and the Robertson Controversy

  1. The first thing I did was to write an email to one particular gay friend and made sure she knew where I stood, both in relation to God, but also in my commitment to stand by her no matter what. It was a heck of a lot longer than that, but she was touched by my concern for her. She was drawing closer to me, but I had also in another way, said what Phil had. The message told 2 ways, yielded 2 different reactions. I believe that you have to build a relationship before you can effectively deliver hard message like this one.

  2. I still struggle to know whether I am an “us” or “them.” Bridges generate better more respectful discourse. Bridges also get walked on. Love (most) of this 😉 Love all of you.

  3. My response to this has nothing to do with being gay or straight. My response is: why is he being reprimanded? I cannot recall another reality show star on another network who was reprimanded and ‘let go’ because their views were too liberal, or they said that being gay was acceptable. Last I checked the other shows are full of sex – of all kinds- drugs, booze and fights. And THAT is fine. I want to be able to respectfully disagree without being labeled a hater. Because I’m not AT ALL. The issue of punishing one view over another is the issue.

    • How about Charlie Sheen?

      The situations were actually quite similar. Both were paid and promoted to be controversial and somewhat shocking (one on the liberal end and the other on the conservative end). But when they got “too shocking” for the networks they were reprimanded/let go/fired.

      I’m not sure this is so much about homosexuality/culture etc as it is about the utter silliness of marketing the shock factor.

  4. So glad you posted this, Julie. Honestly, I’ve been waiting to read your thoughts on this ever since the whole controversy started. Thanks!

  5. Thank you for your post. I hear your heart in it. I deeply desire for the church to stop couching the sins in our culture with an “us versus them” rhetoric. I’m so thankful that Christ came to save all of us, with all our struggles and old nature tendencies. I’ve been disheartened today by some of the responses from folks who, I believe, have played into the stereotypes that the world already has about us. I’ve been thinking what a mess the church is in. But then my wise husband reminded me that Christ, who is the head of the church, can take these kinds of situations and use them for His glory. So my hope is that Christians…starting with myself…will learn how to articulate the gospel and the demands of the gospel in a way that is helpful, truthful, and grace-saturated. Blessings to you, dear sister in Christ.

  6. You talk of ‘statements that imply we’d be straight if we woke up to the glory of the opposite sex’s genitals.’ A sincere question from an Anglican: is it not, albeit very crudely put, what the Roman Catholic church teaches when it speaks of a disordered desire? Isn’t attraction to ‘the opposite sex’s genitals’ (and more) the proper ‘order’ of desire?

  7. Pingback: Why I'd Rather Not Stand with Phil Robertson | NeoReformanda

  8. Shared and shared and shared this! You are so precious!
    It was a hard week and when I ask God why is was so difficult, an image told it all (Not our usual way of communication) I was in a huge church of people All gathered to support Phil (I like Phil) and with their backs to a mom and son, who just didn’t know what to do. But someone pushed through the crowd and it was Jesus, hugging the boy and seeing the good in him, while everyone supported Phil! I like when God talks to me in images. He knew how I felt! People disappoint, Jesus doesn’t!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s